skip to content

Why I’m Not Like Jill Duggar

Ever since Jill Duggar announced her pregnancy seemingly just a few hours after she saw two stripes on a stick, there have been some hearty discussions about the timing of announcing a pregnancy.

When is it appropriate to announce a pregnancy? When is too soon? And is it presumptuous to announce too soon? Does it mean you’re naive to the dangers of the first trimester and the risks of conception? If you wait to make the announcement, does it mean you only believe in the sanctity of a viable pregnancy? If you wait to tell people, does it mean you don’t really believe you were carrying a human life?

I’ve listened to the discussions, and I haven’t weighed in because it’s admittedly a tender topic for me. But sometimes, the tender spots are the ones that need attention.

I’ve been pregnant four times.
I’ve given birth to two children.
I’ve had two miscarriages.

The first time I was pregnant, we told everybody, everywhere, right away. We were elated and ecstatic, so excited to have a baby due on Father’s Day. At nearly eleven weeks, we went in for our first ultrasound and learned that the baby had no heartbeat. My child had died a few days after conception, but my body had never realized it. My body operated as though she were nesting a baby, and I showed all the symptoms of a healthy pregnancy.

The doctor called my pregnancy a ‘missed miscarriage,’ or a ‘spontaneous abortion.’ I remember lying on the crumply paper of the exam table, arching my back and sobbing. I remember feeling Robb’s fingers in my hair and hearing his voice next to my ear.

In addition to our own sadness and a series of procedures to ‘remove the tissue’, we had the endless series of conversations and dozens of phone calls to make. Our families. His colleagues. The young couples in our community who were having their own babies, left and right. My teaching friends. Both of my kindergarten classes. That’s 59 six-year-olds.

Even after we thought that surely everyone who cares must know by now, I saw someone at the mall who congratulated me on the pregnancy. And then we were tangled in the mutual awkwardness of, “Actually…”

It seems like when you want to keep a secret, everyone will find out. When you want to spread the word, it seems like the line of communication keeps getting stalled.

That’s the story of the first baby.

When I was pregnant the second time, I didn’t want to tell anybody. In fact, I didn’t even tell my parents until I was showing symptoms of a second miscarriage. I remember weighing the words, “The good news is I’m pregnant. The bad news is I’m bleeding.”

We kept him a secret for as long as we could, until the bump made the announcement. I carried that baby full term, and that’s the story of Tucker.

When we were expecting again, we held hands as we watched the blinking white light of a heartbeat on the ultrasound screen. Less than a week later, we were in the ER. I looked at the water stains on the ceiling tiles while Robb studied the screen, hoping against hope for that blinking white light on a similar screen.

He was a dad three times over; he knew what he was looking for. There was only stillness. The technician said, “The doctor will give you the results soon,” and he left the room. And my husband said, “I’m sorry, sweetheart.” Because he knew.

When I was pregnant one more time, I held my breath and kept my mouth shut as I waited for the shoe to fall. Bad news never arrived. Instead, my sweet Tyler was born.

Every single one of those ‘positive tests’ is a child to me.

So if I may assert a different perspective, parents who don’t go public right away might not be making a statement about the value of life and the difference between a fetus and a baby.

It’s possible that they can only break their own hearts so many times.

Tricia Lott Williford

Comments are closed

  1. Thanks for being so real and sharing more with us than you ever really had to….

  2. So true. I didn’t even know people were arguing over this! Thank you for sharing your story.

  3. As the mother to 11 children, and after having 3 miscarriages, I can say that there is never a good time to share the information. Children add an interesting complication to that story, because they also share in the grief when a baby is miscarried. There is no special way to explain to a child the sadness or the loss of a baby, even when there is a supportive family. It was very hard for my oldest son when this happened to us, and I was mourning the loss of our baby, and he also was mourning the loss of a sibling. He wanted and needed reassurance as well as needed me to be able to work through the loss.

  4. I would never judge someone either way. I have always shared right away, but that’s mostly because even when I did lose my baby I was in a state of grief that would have been nearly impossible for anyone to miss. At the same time, I totally understand the position of those who don’t share. I’ve had dear friends not tell me until the second trimester (even though I had an idea), and it never occurred to me that they didn’t think their baby was “real.” I knew they didn’t want to go public with heartbreak should the worst happen.

  5. Thank you for opening your heart to us and putting experience and voice into something so tender. I agree, there are many reasons not to share a pregnancy right away and they have nothing to do with not valuing life.

  6. Thank you for this. I am almost 14 weeks into my first pregnancy and resisted telling people until very, very recently, because I could not stand the thought of constantly having to correct my dental hygienist and the guy my dad used to work with and the kids I teach at school if something went wrong. I still worry about it.

    That does not mean that I value this baby any less. And it’s been kind of painful watching some of the conversation about ‘why you should tell earlier’.

    In fact, if I had miscarried before I announced it, I probably would have told my church family what happened. But dealing with it in the past – I was pregnant but there were complications and now I’m not – is easier than constantly having to crush so much joy. You can still respect life and want to be cautious. You can still want the support of a community and want to be cautious.

    Every person should get to decide how big they want that community to be, and how they want to share it.

    • Only the people living it know when the right time is. Great comments!

  7. I admittedly did not read the articles about Jill Dugger’s announcements, but I have seen some of the comments on Facebook and while I’ve never been pregnant, never experienced that kind of joy–or loss–I have dear friends who have. I’ve prayed over them and their babies, that they would carry those children to full term. And they did. But so often they didn’t share that they were pregnant for these same reasons you mention above. Life is precious. Why else would our heart break so desperately when we lose it? Keeping still doesn’t make that life any more precious or valuable. Great post, Tricia. Thank you for lending another perspective!

You Are Safe Now

Available April 9, 2024

This Book Is for You

Now Available
A book about falling in love with the Bible

Just. You. Wait.

Now Available
#1 New Title on Amazon in Christian Inspiration

You Can Do This

Now Available
#1 New Title on Amazon in Women's Issues!

Let's Pretend We're Normal

Now Available
#1 Bestseller on Amazon in Single Parenting

And Life Comes Back

Now Available
#1 in Denver Post: Nonfiction Paperback and Finalist for 2015 Christian Book Award
© 2015-2024 Tricia Lott Williford. All Rights Reserved. Site by Concept To Web.